- Home
- The Concept of Work In Islam According to Kitabosunnat
- Islamic Ruling On Banks Job
- Islamic Ruling On Training In Riba-Based Bank
- Islamic Ruling On Job Interest Loans
- Islamic Ruling On Insurance Job
- Islamic Ruling On fake Job
- Islamic Ruling On Bakery Job
- Islamic Ruling On Haraam Job
- Islamic Ruling On Job In music Shop
- Islamic Ruling On Job Experience
- Islamic Ruling On Working As Sales
- Islamic Ruling On Work In Emergency Department
- Islamic Ruling on Working with Cheater
- Islamic Ruling On Working In A Company that Sells Toys
- Woman Working In The Perfume
- Ruling on Salary,Share And Bonus
- Islamic Ruling On Working In Jewellery Shop
- Working in a call centre
- Ruling On Making Profit
- Islamic Ruling On Tuition Fee
- Working for mail Companies
- Ruling on Give up Work for Prayer
- Ruling On Working in A Paint Shop
- Ruling On Studied In An Institute With A Trick
- Ruling On Working In Haraam Stock
- Islamic Ruling On Taking Tips
- Ruling On Working In A Contraceptive pills Company
- Translating A Book Against Islam
- Ruling On Study & Course for Haraam Job
- Ruling On Using Company's Properties for Personal
- Work In A Government Department
- Opening An Account In The Bank
- Ruling On A Doctor Who Misses The Prayer
- Ruling On Working As An Accountant
- Ruling On Taking Payment for Interpreting Dreams
- Ruling On Students Job
- Making Loans Easy for Bank Customers
- He worked for his father in return for payment
- Ruling On Renting Out The Hotel
- It Is Not Permissible for You Not to Fast Because of Work
- Ruling On Working As Producer
- Islimic Ruling On Nurse Job
- Ruling On Working In The Tourism Field As A Booking Agent
- Ruling On Accept Payment For Additional Work
- Ruling On Changing One's Date of Birth
- Ruling on Mosque’s Employees
- Arranging Hotel Reservations for Travellers
- A Teacher Worked Some Additional Hours
- Ruling On Jury Duty In A Non-Islamic Court In A Non-Muslim Country
- Working In A Mixed Environment
- Using Company Car for Personal Purposes
- Ruling On Owning, Renting
- Ruling On Working In A Cafe
- Ruling On Working In The Saudi Investment Bank
- Working In Auditing Offices
- Ruling On Diagnostic Medical Imaging
- Ruling On Working In An Islamic Nasheed Group
- Ruling On Working In A Law Company
- Ruling on Demand for Salary Increase
- Ruling On A Woman Working As A Broadcaster
- Ruling On Building Tourist Resorts
- He Got A Promotion At Work Via Bribery
- Ruling On Investing In Internet Cafes
- Doing Hajj With Money He Earned
- Working In Administration Supervised
- What Are Haraam Types of Jobs?
- Benefiting From Experience Acquired In A Haraam Job
- Ruling On Working As A Physical Education Teacher
- She Had A Contract To Work For Two
- Working In A Riba-based Bank With No Pay
- Working On A Program Which Helps
- Difference In Quality Of Teaching
- Using School Equipment for Personal
- Ruling On Training In A Riba-based Bank
- The Head Of The Department Lets Them
- Should He Tell On An Employee Who
- Ruling On Studying Accountancy
- Signing Up With A Lawyers’ Syndicate
- Ruling On Producing TV Reports
- Ruling On Receiving Salary Via A Riba-based Bank
- Ruling On Working In The Manufacture Of Pet Food
- The Imam And Muazzin Are
- Ruling On Working In A Shop
- Islamic Ruling On Google AdSense
- Changing One’s Age On The ID Card
- Working In Construction Or Painting
- Islamic Ruling On One Who Is Employed To Move Haraam
- He Wants To Open A Shop But
- Islamic Ruling On Working In A Company That Deals Alcohol
- The Administration Of The Blood Bank
- Ruling On Working On A Program
- False Medical Excuses Used By Students And Employees
- Working As An Intermediary
- Should He Submit A False Report
- Ruling On Opening A Barbershop For Men
- Giving Lessons Outside Of School
- Ruling On Working In A Programming Company
- Working In The Islamic Section Of A Bank
- Ruling On Taking Part And Working In Savings Accounts
- She Has Given Up Working As A Pharmacist
- Working Washing Glasses Used For Wine
- The Boss Distributed To Them Money
- Does Accepting Payment For Teaching Qur’aan And Arabic
- Ruling On Shop For Audio Repairing
- The Boss Lets Them Record A Half Day As A Full Day
- Ruling On Working In Al-Rajhi Bank
- He Is Being Asked To Erase The Faults
- Using The Computer At Work For Personal Reasons
- Working In An Internet Café
- Should She Take Her Salary Without Working?
- He Saved The Government Some Money
- Ruling On Disposing Of Samples After Testing Them
- He Got A Forged Certificate
- Boss Choosing A Female Secretary For The Workplace
- Should He Sit With His Colleagues At Work
- Employment In Private And Government Sectors
- She Completes Her Evening Work Before The Time Ends
- She Works In A Store And Some Money Was Stolen
- Forging Certificates In Order To Gain Employment
- Can An Employee Take Promotional Items
- Working In Production Of Electronic Chips
- Can The Teacher Repeat The Exam So That The Students Will Get Better
- He Is Working In A Store And Is Afraid
- She Received A Proposal From An Engineer
- Deducting From An Employees Wages Because Of His Mistakes
- She Works In A Residence For Foreign Female Students
- They Are Playing About With Their Attendance
- Teachers leaving before the end of working hours
- Ruling On Going On Strike
- She Works In A Company Is Owned
- Should He Give The Telephone Worker A Tip Even Though He Has A
- Ruling On Job In A Hotel
- Working As A Storekeeper In A Hotel Where There Is Alcohol
- She Works For A Company That Is
- Ruling On Working For Newspapers
- Can He Work As A Typist In A Law Office That Defends Criminals?
- Working In The Construction
- Ruling On Dealing In Cosmetics And Hairdressers’ Supplies
- Ruling On A Man Teaching Girls Without Any Barrier
- Is It Permissible For An Employee To Read Qur’aan During Work Hours?
- He Works As An Accountant In A Company
- Students Working In Restaurants That Serve Alcohol And Pork
- Workplace Questions etc.
- Asking About The Circumstances
- Reading Qur’aan During Work Time
- Ruling On Telling Bosses About A Worker
- Should A Boss Agree To Give Permission
- He Wants To Work Some Days Of
- Ruling On Working As A Film Developer
- Is It Permissible To Work As A Lawyer?
- Her Relative’s Husband Went Against
- What Is The Ruling on Professional Pursuit Of Football
- Salary Of An Employee Who Cheated In his Exam
- Ruling On Working As A Defence Lawyer
- Ruling On Female Servants Working
- Ruling On Talking To Women At Work
- Should He Take What He Entitled
- Doing One’s Own Work During Official Work Hours
- His Job Is Making Sure That The Company’s Files Are Recorded
- Is It Permissible To Work In A Mint?
- Ruling On Tips For Workers And The Ruling On Working
- Working For A Company That Sells Gold On Credit
- Can He Open A Store To Do Cupping In Return For Payment?
- Ruling On Appointing A Woman As A Judge
- He Works In A Company In Which There Is A Restaurant That Sells
- Should He Shave His Beard For The Sake Of Work ?
- A Teacher Uses His Teaching Time
- Ruling On Salary If One Acquired The Certificate By Cheating
- Is His Preferring To Work With Non-Muslims
- Ruling On Working In Bank al-Bilaad
- Working As A Customs Broker And The Wages Of A Broker
- Should He Pay Money In Order To Get A Job?
- He Got His University Certificate Through An Intermediary
- Is it Permissible for A Woman to Work Selling Product Over The Phone
- Is it Permissible to Delay Payment
- Writing A Letter Stating Salary for Someone Who Will Use it to Get A
- Should He Travel To Kaafir Countries Or Work In A Tourist Resort?
- It Is Hard For Him To Go To Work So He Signs
- (1)He works In A Mixed Environment And Is Worried About His Fast
- Is It Permissible For Him To Sell Gifts
- Ruling on Working for A Company that Maintains the Central Bank Building
- He Refuses to Teach Music to the Students,and he Is Asking About His
- Ruling on Working As The Manager of an Internet Café
- Ruling On Taking Part In Building A Resort Village
- Using The Company’s Property For Personal Things
- Ruling on Working As A Security Guard In An Hotel
- It Is Permissible To Accept Payment For Teaching Qur’aan
- He Works In A Video Game Store And Is Asking About His Income
- A Muslim Working For An Atheist
- He Works As The Deputy Manager In A Hotel That Sells Alcohol
- Ruling on Teaching Man-made Laws
- Working As A Lawyer In A Country That Is Ruled
- Working As A Lawyer In The Islamic Judicial System
- Ruling on Working In A Company That Promotes Satellite Channels
- A Security Guard Sleeping When He Has Nothing To Do
- Ruling on Fixing TVs And VCRs
- He Told The Students To Pay Money
- Is It Permissible For Her To Pray In Front Of Employees At Work?
- He Wants To Work In A Company That Produces Programs For
- He Treated The Financial Director And He Gave Him Some Money
- Writing Down People’s Complaints
- If There Is Half An Hour Left Of The Regular Work Hours Of A Field
- Important And Precise Conditions For Committing An Evil Action By Forc
- Ruling on A Man Working In A Hairdressing Salon For Women
- Working For A Company That Cheats
- Secrets In The Medical Profession
Deducting From An Employees Wages Because Of His Mistakes
We work in a company that punishes employees for mistakes by deducting one or two days’ pay from their wages. This is not based on any specific law about deductions, rather the deductions are made according to what the boss thinks. But we are angry because a deduction may be made because of a very minor mistake. Is it o.k. for us to use some of the work time for our own business, commensurate with what has been deducted wrongfully from our wages? Do they have the right to wrong us in this manner? Please note that this was not discussed when the contract was drawn up.
Praise be to Allah.
Firstly:
The employee in the public or private sector is a “private worker” according to the terminology of shariah, and the private worker is the one with whom a contract has been made stating that he will work for the hirer for a specific length of time. This is the case with jobs nowadays, where there is an agreement on set number of working hours each day.
The fuqaha’ have explained the ruling on private workers at length in their books.
One of these rulings is that the worker does not deserve the wages agreed upon (salary) unless he completes the work required of him as agreed in the contract.
It says in al-Mawsoo’ah al-Fiqhiyyah (1/292):
The boss is required to pay the worker in return for his making himself available, so long as he does not refuse to do the work that is required of him. If he refuses with no good reason, then he is not entitled to his wages, and there is no difference of scholarly opinion on this point. End quote.
It says in Fatawa al-Lajnah ad-Daa’imah (15/153):
The one who is entrusted with some work in return for a salary is required to do the work in the manner required. If he fails to do that with no valid reason, then it is not permissible for him to take the salary. End quote.
Secondly:
If an employee makes a mistake or destroys something (such as one of the machines or tools that he is working with), is he liable to pay for it or not?
The answer is that one of two scenarios must apply. If that was due to a transgression or shortcoming on his part, such as if he was using the machine or equipment in the wrong way, which led to it breaking, or he overworked the machine, or he did not do his work properly, or he was careless in his work, etc., in this case he is liable to replace what he destroyed, and there is no difference of opinion among the fuqaha’. The employer may deduct the value of the damaged item from the employee’s salary.
In the second scenario, if the damage was done with no transgression or shortcoming on his part, then there is a difference of opinion among the scholars. The view of the majority is that he is not liable unless he transgressed or fell short. Others (such as Imam al-Shaafa’i, according to one of his two opinions) were of the view that he is liable.
See: Takmilat al-Majmoo’ (15/354) and al-Mawsoo’ah al-Fiqhiyyah (1/290).
This issue is one that is subject to ijtihaad. If the employer, whether it is an individual or a company follows the view that the employee’s is liable, then the employer is not to be blamed for deductions that are made, provided that the deduction is commensurate with the mistaken and is done in a fair manner. But if the company and the employee disagree on what is fair, then referral for judgement between them should be made to the shar’i qaadi.
But if the employee makes a mistake that does not result in damage to or loss of property, such as if he is late in coming to work or he is absent without an excuse, and so on, then can the boss deduct something from his salary in return for that, or not?
The answer is: Yes, he may do that, and some of these deductions may be stipulated in the contract or in the regulations governing the company. Moreover, this is something that is very common. The employee works for the company and he knows that if he falls short in his work or goes against the company’s regulations, he will face the consequences, one of which is deduction from his salary. Even if it is not stated in his contract, this is well known and is customary in the workplace.
But the company owner or boss should strive to be fair and avoid being unfair. The deduction should be commensurate with the shortcoming or mistake, and the penalty should not be exaggerated.
The scholars of the Standing Committee were asked:
When I fire a supervisor or worker, or make harsh deductions in order to set things straight, is this haraam?
They replied:
It is not permissible to deduct salaries from employees or fire them except in accordance within the framework dictated by the regulations set out by those who are in charge. End quote.
Fatawa al-Lajnah ad-Daa’imah (23/410).
Thirdly:
You have made a number of mistakes, as mentioned in the question. If you find that the deduction is greater than the mistake warrants, or that it was a minor mistake of a type for which deductions are not made in other companies, then the only option you have is to make a complaint to those who are in charge of the company, and explain your point of view. If they insist and you are not convinced of their argument, then you can refer to the shar’i court to judge fairly between you, in sha Allah.
But with regard to your deliberately being absent, coming late or falling short in your work, or taking back what has been deducted in ways that are not Islamically acceptable – as some employees do – as a response to the disputed issue, that is not the way of the believers and it is not permissible to do that, because taking back contested rights can only be done through the shar’i courts, and cannot be done on the basis of people’s whims and desires and opinions.
The scholars of the Standing Committee were asked:
If a person steals or takes something without permission from his workplace in return for a deduction from his salary, is this regarded as stealing and as haraam?
They replied:
Yes, this is regarded as haraam, and if he has a clear case he may ask for his rights from the authorities. End quote.
Fatawa al-Lajnah ad-Daa’imah (19/221)
In Fatawa al-Lajnah (15/123) it also says that the committee was asked about an employee who was mistreated by his boss who deducted from his salary. They replied:
If there is a dispute between you and him, then you have to refer to the shar’i court to examine your case. It is not permissible for you to take anything from his wealth without his permission or knowledge. End quote.
They also said (15/144):
It is not permissible for you to take from the boss the equivalent of what is owing to you without his knowledge, but you have the right to demand what he owes to you through Islamically acceptable means, even if that involves referring to the courts. End quote.
Shaykh Ibn Baaz (may Allah have mercy on him) was asked the following question in Fatawa Noor ‘ala ad-Darb (tape no. 410):
There is a young man who was working in a company, but the company suddenly deducted something from me with no good reason. This is one problem. I also did some work for which I deserved to be rewarded and they did not give me any reward. I resorted to doing the following: When I bought something for the company, I would get a big discount from the storekeepers, but that was between me and the storekeepers. I would keep the discount in my pocket, so the invoice would say one hundred pounds, and I would keep twenty-five pounds but the invoice would say one hundred. Please note that the prices on the invoice are similar to the prices in regular stores and the value shown on the invoice is no greater than it would be ordinarily, but what happens is that I get a discount because I buy in large quantities and the discount is not shown on the invoice. Please advise us in the light of that.
He replied:
What you have to do is to explain to them so that things will be clear. You may be mistaken in what you are claiming as your right. So you should set things straight between you and them, with the intervention of arbitrators or the courts, or between you and them directly. This is what you should do, so that you will not take more than you are entitled to. End quote.
And Allah knows best.
Islam Q&A
Praise be to Allah.
Firstly:
The employee in the public or private sector is a “private worker” according to the terminology of shariah, and the private worker is the one with whom a contract has been made stating that he will work for the hirer for a specific length of time. This is the case with jobs nowadays, where there is an agreement on set number of working hours each day.
The fuqaha’ have explained the ruling on private workers at length in their books.
One of these rulings is that the worker does not deserve the wages agreed upon (salary) unless he completes the work required of him as agreed in the contract.
It says in al-Mawsoo’ah al-Fiqhiyyah (1/292):
The boss is required to pay the worker in return for his making himself available, so long as he does not refuse to do the work that is required of him. If he refuses with no good reason, then he is not entitled to his wages, and there is no difference of scholarly opinion on this point. End quote.
It says in Fatawa al-Lajnah ad-Daa’imah (15/153):
The one who is entrusted with some work in return for a salary is required to do the work in the manner required. If he fails to do that with no valid reason, then it is not permissible for him to take the salary. End quote.
Secondly:
If an employee makes a mistake or destroys something (such as one of the machines or tools that he is working with), is he liable to pay for it or not?
The answer is that one of two scenarios must apply. If that was due to a transgression or shortcoming on his part, such as if he was using the machine or equipment in the wrong way, which led to it breaking, or he overworked the machine, or he did not do his work properly, or he was careless in his work, etc., in this case he is liable to replace what he destroyed, and there is no difference of opinion among the fuqaha’. The employer may deduct the value of the damaged item from the employee’s salary.
In the second scenario, if the damage was done with no transgression or shortcoming on his part, then there is a difference of opinion among the scholars. The view of the majority is that he is not liable unless he transgressed or fell short. Others (such as Imam al-Shaafa’i, according to one of his two opinions) were of the view that he is liable.
See: Takmilat al-Majmoo’ (15/354) and al-Mawsoo’ah al-Fiqhiyyah (1/290).
This issue is one that is subject to ijtihaad. If the employer, whether it is an individual or a company follows the view that the employee’s is liable, then the employer is not to be blamed for deductions that are made, provided that the deduction is commensurate with the mistaken and is done in a fair manner. But if the company and the employee disagree on what is fair, then referral for judgement between them should be made to the shar’i qaadi.
But if the employee makes a mistake that does not result in damage to or loss of property, such as if he is late in coming to work or he is absent without an excuse, and so on, then can the boss deduct something from his salary in return for that, or not?
The answer is: Yes, he may do that, and some of these deductions may be stipulated in the contract or in the regulations governing the company. Moreover, this is something that is very common. The employee works for the company and he knows that if he falls short in his work or goes against the company’s regulations, he will face the consequences, one of which is deduction from his salary. Even if it is not stated in his contract, this is well known and is customary in the workplace.
But the company owner or boss should strive to be fair and avoid being unfair. The deduction should be commensurate with the shortcoming or mistake, and the penalty should not be exaggerated.
The scholars of the Standing Committee were asked:
When I fire a supervisor or worker, or make harsh deductions in order to set things straight, is this haraam?
They replied:
It is not permissible to deduct salaries from employees or fire them except in accordance within the framework dictated by the regulations set out by those who are in charge. End quote.
Fatawa al-Lajnah ad-Daa’imah (23/410).
Thirdly:
You have made a number of mistakes, as mentioned in the question. If you find that the deduction is greater than the mistake warrants, or that it was a minor mistake of a type for which deductions are not made in other companies, then the only option you have is to make a complaint to those who are in charge of the company, and explain your point of view. If they insist and you are not convinced of their argument, then you can refer to the shar’i court to judge fairly between you, in sha Allah.
But with regard to your deliberately being absent, coming late or falling short in your work, or taking back what has been deducted in ways that are not Islamically acceptable – as some employees do – as a response to the disputed issue, that is not the way of the believers and it is not permissible to do that, because taking back contested rights can only be done through the shar’i courts, and cannot be done on the basis of people’s whims and desires and opinions.
The scholars of the Standing Committee were asked:
If a person steals or takes something without permission from his workplace in return for a deduction from his salary, is this regarded as stealing and as haraam?
They replied:
Yes, this is regarded as haraam, and if he has a clear case he may ask for his rights from the authorities. End quote.
Fatawa al-Lajnah ad-Daa’imah (19/221)
In Fatawa al-Lajnah (15/123) it also says that the committee was asked about an employee who was mistreated by his boss who deducted from his salary. They replied:
If there is a dispute between you and him, then you have to refer to the shar’i court to examine your case. It is not permissible for you to take anything from his wealth without his permission or knowledge. End quote.
They also said (15/144):
It is not permissible for you to take from the boss the equivalent of what is owing to you without his knowledge, but you have the right to demand what he owes to you through Islamically acceptable means, even if that involves referring to the courts. End quote.
Shaykh Ibn Baaz (may Allah have mercy on him) was asked the following question in Fatawa Noor ‘ala ad-Darb (tape no. 410):
There is a young man who was working in a company, but the company suddenly deducted something from me with no good reason. This is one problem. I also did some work for which I deserved to be rewarded and they did not give me any reward. I resorted to doing the following: When I bought something for the company, I would get a big discount from the storekeepers, but that was between me and the storekeepers. I would keep the discount in my pocket, so the invoice would say one hundred pounds, and I would keep twenty-five pounds but the invoice would say one hundred. Please note that the prices on the invoice are similar to the prices in regular stores and the value shown on the invoice is no greater than it would be ordinarily, but what happens is that I get a discount because I buy in large quantities and the discount is not shown on the invoice. Please advise us in the light of that.
He replied:
What you have to do is to explain to them so that things will be clear. You may be mistaken in what you are claiming as your right. So you should set things straight between you and them, with the intervention of arbitrators or the courts, or between you and them directly. This is what you should do, so that you will not take more than you are entitled to. End quote.
And Allah knows best.
Islam Q&A